Four German wheel recalls: when a wheel fails, the car gets called back
Short answer
Two things changed for replacement wheels, and most exporters only know the first.
| Change | What it means |
|---|---|
| Regulation (EU) 2018/858 | Components need approval before they can be placed on the market |
| Regulation (EU) 2019/2144, from 7 July 2024 | A replacement wheel without UN R124 approval may not be placed on the market or put into service at all |
Germany’s type-approval authority (KBA) put the consequence plainly in a 2024 notice: from that date, the manufacturer must ensure that every wheel falling within the R124 definition has the corresponding approval — including wheels that already held a national approval under §22 StVZO.
And when a wheel is the problem, the remedy is not a delisting. It is a recall from end users.
The four cases
All four were notified by Germany. All four list the country of origin as the People’s Republic of China. All four ended the same way.
| Date | Alert | Product | Brand on the alert | Defect |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022-03-04 | A12/00379/22 | Wheel rims (motorcycle) | Craftride | Defective production may cause cracks |
| 2022-06-17 | A12/00873/22 | Replacement wheels for cars | Zhejiang Xinghui Aluminium Wheel Co., Ltd | Manufacturing defect may cause the rim to break while moving |
| 2022-07-22 | A12/01035/22 | Replacement wheels | D-CARS Performance GmbH | Insufficient structural durability — cracks in the spokes and at the rim base |
| 2024-06-14 | A12/01530/24 | Wheel hub | Meyle | Defective hardening may let the rear wheel detach |
Measure taken, in every case: “Recall of the product from end users”, ordered against the manufacturer.
Compare that with the brake pad alerts from July–August 2025: those ended with a marketplace delisting in Ireland, and a marketing ban in Belgium. Cheaper, faster, and over.
A wheel that cracks at speed cannot be fixed by removing a listing. The cars are already on the road, and the wheels are already on the cars.
What R124 actually covers
The scope article is short, and it excludes more than people expect:
“This Regulation covers new replacement wheels designed for vehicles of categories M1, M1G, N1, N1G, O1 and O2.” — UN Regulation No. 124, paragraph 1, as amended
And then:
“It does not apply to original equipment wheels or vehicle manufacturer’s replacement wheels … It does not apply to ‘Special wheels’ … which shall remain subjected to national approval.” — same paragraph
So the regulation is about new replacement wheels for passenger cars and their trailers. M1 is a passenger car; O1 and O2 are light trailers. N1 and N1G — light commercial vehicles and their off-road variants — were added by Amendment 3. If you are selling wheels for a heavy truck, this is not your regulation; that does not make the wheel unregulated, it makes it a different question.
“Special wheels” keep national approval. That is the door the KBA notice closes for any wheel that also happens to be a replacement wheel under R124: a national approval no longer stands on its own, because the R124 obligation applies on top of it.
The part that costs money: “wheel type”
R124 does not approve a brand, and it does not approve a factory. It approves a wheel type, and the regulation defines that type by a list of characteristics:
| Characteristic | Why it matters commercially |
|---|---|
| Manufacturer | A second factory is a different approval question |
| Wheel or rim size designation | Diameter and width |
| Construction materials | Aluminium alloy, steel, magnesium — different material, different type |
| Wheel attachment holes | PCD and centre bore |
| Maximum load capacity | A load rating is part of the type, not a sticker |
| Recommended maximum inflation pressure | |
| Method of production | Welded, forged, cast |
| Styling | Spoke pattern |
Change the styling or the offset family, and you may be outside the approved type — even if the drawing “looks the same”.
And the tests are not cheap to redo. Annexes 4 and 6 to 8 require material analysis, a corrosion test, a rotating bending test, a rolling test, and an impact test. For identical or replica replacement wheels, the sample count per type runs to ten.
There is also a rule that catches wide product ranges: where a type contains more than two versions with different PCD, and a version differs from a tested one by more than 6.5 mm, that version needs its own test. A catalogue built on “one approval, fifteen fitments” does not survive contact with that sentence.
What the approval file has to match
This is the practical checklist, and it is the thing a customs or market-surveillance officer will ask for:
- Regulation and amendment level referenced (current text, not the 2007 original)
- Approval authority and the country identifier in the approval number
- Approval number, complete
- Approval holder — the legal entity, not a trading name
- Manufacturing location(s)
- Wheel type designation
- Material and production method
- Diameter, width, offset, PCD, centre bore, rated load
- Approved vehicle types or vehicle-type identifiers
- Permitted tyre combinations
- Required fasteners, centre rings, spacers
- Approval-mark format and location
- The technical report, and conformity-of-production evidence
The two bolded lines are where Chinese catalogue sellers most often fall short. An approval number on the box, with no documented vehicle application behind it, is an approval for a wheel that nobody has established a fitment for.
What to do
-
Get the approval document, not the approval number. The number is public. The document says which vehicles and which tyres it covers.
-
Check which amendment level the approval references. Supplement 3 (in force January 2022) added the PCD test rule and the replica comparison method. An approval from 2015 does not reflect the current text.
-
Treat every new size, offset family, material or spoke design as a new approval question, and price it that way in the quotation. “Same drawing, different offset” is a sentence that ends in a recall.
-
If you hold a national approval, read the KBA-style condition. Many approvals now carry a restriction: the wheel may only be used where the combination is not already approved by the vehicle manufacturer — unless you also hold R124.
-
Put the fitment table on the product page and in the box. The document that saves you in a market-surveillance check is the one the buyer can also read.
Where exporters get it wrong
They buy a test report and call it an approval. A TÜV or equivalent laboratory report is evidence inside a type-approval process. It is not the approval, and it does not define the vehicle application.
They assume one approval covers the catalogue. R124 approves a type defined by eight characteristics. A 17-inch and an 18-inch version of the “same” wheel are not the same type.
They think the approval is about strength only. Half of the file is documentation: approval holder, factory, approved vehicles, permitted tyres, fasteners. A structurally perfect wheel with the wrong paperwork fails the same check.
They underrate the remedy. A delisting costs a week of sales. A recall costs the goods, the freight, the labour, and the customer. Of the twenty Chinese-origin component alerts in this database since 2016, the wheel cases are the ones that ended in recalls.
Version and dates
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Regulation | UN Regulation No. 124, uniform provisions concerning the approval of wheels for passenger cars and their trailers |
| Amendment level cited | Supplement 3 to the 00 series, in force 7 January 2022 |
| EU obligation | Regulation (EU) 2019/2144 — R124 approval required for replacement wheels from 7 July 2024 |
| Alerts cited | A12/00379/22, A12/00873/22, A12/01035/22, A12/01530/24 |
| Last checked | 17 November 2026 |
| Official source | UNECE R124 text, Safety Gate, KBA notice IST 06-24 |
Approval-file contents are described from the regulation’s application articles and annexes, in general terms. Confirm the current amendment level and the applicable vehicle categories before relying on this note.
Scope. This article summarises publicly available regulatory texts as of UN Regulation No. 124 (including Supplement 3, in force 7 January 2022); Regulation (EU) 2019/2144, applicable from 7 July 2024. Requirements change; verify against the official source before acting.
Not legal advice. This is an information service, not a legal opinion, and it does not create any professional relationship. For decisions specific to your product, consult a qualified professional or the competent authority.
Sources. EUR-Lex, UK Legislation, eCFR and UNECE regulation texts, linked inline where applicable.